The shawshank redeption book vs movie add a difference. Whats the difference between rita hayworth and shawshank redemption the book and the shawshank redeption the movie. Compare and contrast shawshank redemption free essays. Theme of hope in the shawshank redemption 615 words cram. The shawshank redemption is a prison movie that is based on a book by stephen king and directed by frank darabont. This movie, the shawshank redemption, starring tim robbins and morgan freeman, is an american prison drama. How the shawshank redemption is an ideal adaptation from. Captain hadley is the lead guard for the entire duration of andys stay. In 1994, the director frank darabont released the movie the shawshank redemption. Andy uses two rock hammers during his excavation of the rock wall. Apr 03, 2012 comparing the book and movie of the shawshank redemption is like comparing a warm chocolate chip cookie and a brownie right out of the oven.
Then, after the escape, he snaps all the black money away. Differences in the movie and book of shawshank redemption essaysthe novella the shawshank redemption and rita hayworth, by stephen king, is the basis. Following a successful release in the 1990s, the shawshank redemption has gone to become one of the most beloved and acclaimed movies ever made. Differences in the movie and book of shawshank redemption essays. This movie is an american drama film which was directed and written by frank darabont in 1994. Tim robbins and morgan freeman are terrific in their roles, as well as the rest of the cast. In the movies, red is played by morgan freeman and. Book vs movie the shawshank redemption 25th anniversary. The shawshank redemption for my film analysis, i chose the movie the shawshank redemption. This film is regarded widely as one of the greatest movies of all time, and it is not hard to see why. Sep 20, 2019 book vs movie the shawshank redemption replay the margos celebrate the 25th anniversary of this classic film if there is one thing we can say about book vs movie fansthey love the stephen king eps and cannot get enough of them.
Many people have cited this movie as having changed their lives for the better when they were going through difficult times in their personal or professional lives. There are a ton of differences between the book and the classic 1994 film adaptation, directed by frank darabont, but those differences lie in the decision to expand the character arcs in the book. If there is one thing we can say about book vs movie fansthey love the stephen king eps and cannot get enough of them. The movie was made in 1994 and produced by niki marvin. The shawshank redemption short story comparison of the film. The shanshank redemption the movie the shawshank redemption, written and directed by frank darabont and based on a novel by stephen king, displays excitement and suspense. Mercifully free of cheap horror and overwrought dialogue, this 1994 release celebrates the resilience of the human spirit. The novella is written by stephen king and is titled. When it was released in 1994, the movie barely recouped its budget, and it took years before. Unlike the book, andy has a revenge on shawshank in the movie, so the delight is more intense. Editions for rita hayworth and shawshank redemption. There were only a few minor changes made in the process from making the book into a motion picture film. The character has the same name in both the book and the movie.
Evidence that support such reasoning develops in the case that a film or movie usually develops from a book or piece of literature kermode, 216. In the movies, red is played by morgan freeman and hes not irish. What movie do you think is better the godfather or the. I was a bit nervous about watching the shawshank redemption for the first time a couple of years ago. The book and novella still have their differences but there similarities stand out. This moving and inspirational film follows the book very closely in relation to the characters and plot, however, it does include some very significant changes. Rita hayworth was the girl on the poster that andy used to hide the hole that he was digging. I choose to look at andy and red as dual protagonists. Rita hayworth and the shawshank redemption is the story of andy. In order so survive in jail, he withstands rape, beatings, and many other forms of punishment.
Seventeen slides on the differences of rita hayworth and the shawshank redemption printed material by stephen king and the film version. I highly recommend checking out kings novella and shawshanks shooting script. What are the differences between shawshank redemption book. In particular, we have been getting requests for the shawshank redemption since we launched the show and finally had the time to get it together. There are many themes represented in each form of the shawshank redemption. It portrays the story of a successful banker who evidences the cruelties and abuses held in prisons. Book vs movie the shawshank redemption the margos finally take on this classic stephen kingfrank darabont movie youre welcome. Andys metamorphosis from lanky new fish to a man of prestige was definitely interesting. Shawshank redemption novella and film compare and contrast the 1994 film the shawshank redemption takes it inspiration from the stephen king novella rita hayworth and the shawshank redemption, the first of four stories collected in his 1982 book different seasons. Sep 20, 2016 whats your favourite stephen king booktoscreen adaptation.
One thing i and many others love about the movie is the ability it has to all come together at the end. Its been number 1 on imdbs top 250 movies since 2008 which is kind of funny since it was a bit of a slow burner at the box office upon release, and i was going to be watching it with a group of friends who kept reassuring me how brilliant it was. The film actors include tim robbins acting as andrew andy dufresne with morgan freeman acting as ellis boyd red redding. In this episode of whats the difference, we break it all down. The horror here is not of the supernatural kind, but of the sort that flows from the realization than 10, 20, 30 years of a mans life have unreeled in the same unchanging daily prison routine. The one major theme that interests me in both the film and the story is freedom. Rita hayworth is an american actress from the 1940s. In the movie there are several lead guards during andys time at shawshank. The movie is directed by frank darabont and is called. The shawshank redemption is perhaps one of those rare films that have eclipsed their source material. Summary of the shawshank redemption film studies essay.
The shawshank redemption 1994 add a movie to the comparison. Visit cinefix for more episodes and movierelated content. King, which was adapted for the screen in 1994 by the director frank darabont. The shawshank redemption aqa, the examination board, has asked selected pupils to submit written reports on possible films to be studied for the media section of the gcse english exam, specifically of the the shawshank redemption. When it comes down to it, they both hit that sweet spot and are better than the other during the moment you are eating them. Tim robbins character andy gave an excellent illustration on how new prisoners enter a world of unknown dangers and survive. The film stars tim robbins as andy dufresne and morgan freeman as ellis boyd red redding. The characters of the movie are played so well that it appears as if it is all real. Dec 06, 2010 differences between the movie and book. Just mercy and the shawshank redemption compare and contrast throughout the reading of just mercy, a novel written by bryan stevenson, and the movie the shawshank redemption, there are many examples that represent the corruption within the criminal justice system. Shawshank redemption rita haywort and the shawshank redemption was first presented in 1982, by stephen king and hooked the hearts of the worlds readers. Freedom in the shawshank redemption essay example for. The way shawshank redemption is portrayed with similarities and differences between the novella and the movie is that the plot and climax are completely different. Surprisingly, there were more similarities between the.
It tells the story of banker andy dufresne tim robbins, who is sentenced to life in shawshank state penitentiary for the murders of his wife and her lover, despite his. The cold light of day 2012, before i go to sleep 2014, armored 2009, acrimony 2018, secret in their eyes 2015. Andys changed life in the film, shawshank redemption, directed by frank darabont, insight was given to the life of prisoners in bondage. Comparison of just mercy and shawshank redemption 981 words. I dont think that the dark knight comes close in any of those categories apart from acting by heath ledger as the joker. There are a ton of differences between the book and the classic 1994 film adaptation. It tells the story of banker andy dufresne tim robbins, who is sentenced to life in shawshank state penitentiary for the murders of his wife and her lover, despite his claims of innocence. A modern american classic celebrated its 20th anniversary in high style at the academy on november 18, 2014, when cast and crew members reunited at a special screening of the shawshank redemption hosted by world war z author max brooks nominated for seven academy awards, the film was released in the fall of 1994 and marked the feature directorial debut of its screenwriter, frank darabont. While the film retains much of the novellas plot and structure, it nonetheless diverges in key areas, such. Frank darabont directed shawshank and wrote the screenplay based on the novel rita hayworth and shawshank redemption by author stephen king. For detailed analysis on the shawshank redemption, check out my shawshank redemption screenplay analysis. Shawshank redemption books that are made into movies are always changed, even if they are minor changes, but changes are made nonetheless. Moreover, he tells on a newspaper company about all the cruelty and corruption of shawshank.
It was adapted for the screen in 1994 as the shawshank redemption, which was nominated for seven academy awards in 1994, including best. When it was released in 1994, the movie barely recouped its budget, and it took years before it was counted among the best films ever made. Aug 20, 2011 its not uncommon for films to differ from their source material. The novella the shawshank redemption and rita hayworth, by stephen king, is the basis of the 1994 movie the shawshank redemption directed by frank darabont. The personalities of the inmatesare very interesting and when they are combined they create a very fascinatingplot which looks at prison life in a interesting and different perspective thanone normally thinks. It has been thought to be loosely based on leo tolstoys 1872 short story god sees the truth, but waits. The shawshank redemption by stephen king is both a wonderful film and a brilliantly written short story. The only really major difference between the king and darabont versions is the casting of morgan freeman as red. In the book, a man called andy dufresne finds himself falsely imprisoned. The shawshank redemption was never a summer blockbuster or a critically acclaimed behemoth of a film but it is widely regarded now as one of the best american films of alltime. The ending, the beginning, the whole movie is just exciting, entertaining, and lastly, puzzling. Shawshank redemption is a spectacular movie full of excitement and it contains many dramatic scenes which have a very large impact on the atmosphere and the audience. A lot of book adaptations usually have more differences than similarities, but the shawshank redemption is completely the opposite. My take is the shawshank redemption is an example of a dual protagonist story.
The shawshank redemption is more than just a prison movie, because it has a very amazing storyline or plot that deals with finding hope, freedom, and solace. Comparison and contrast of a book the shawshank redemption to its movie version the film industry plays a significant role that models the contemporary society. The shawshank redemption is no exception and was in my opinion a great book as well as an excellent movie. King and basically narrates the same story, the film is still quite different from the novella, especially in some details and. Book vs movie the shawshank redemption 25th anniversary special. In the movie tommy williams is moved to a different prison after andy tells the warden that he has information that might free him. Jun 25, 2009 shawshank redemption is an amazing film with some of the best acting, cinematography, music and script i have ever seen heard.
Eventually, just before the police capture norton, norton commits suicide. Comparing the book and movie of the shawshank redemption is like comparing a warm chocolate chip cookie and a brownie right out of the oven. Here is an analysis of the movie with andy as a protagonist figure. King books had been notoriously difficult to bring to the screen. Editions of rita hayworth and shawshank redemption. Performances from tim robbins, new inmate andy dufresne, and morgan freeman, the movie is a drama set in. Differences in the movie and book of shawshank redemption. The shawshank redemptionthe shawshank redemption is a very unique movie which involves manydifferent personalities and underlying themes. The novella was published in 1982 in king s collection entitled different seasons. Rita hayworth and the shawshank redemption, film vs. Free essays on shawshank redemption comparison moive v s book. Having just finished reading the book an hour ago, i can name a few. Shawshank redemption and the green mile movie comparison free.
It did not receive a single award because it was in the shadows. Im not sure how many discussions have taken place on here, comparing story to movie, but i just read rita hayworth and the shawshank redemption out of different seasons, by stephen king, along with watching the shawshank redemption, right after, and wanted to get some thoughts of others who may have done this not backtoback, of course. Throughout the film darabont defines the redemptive power of hope. There were only a few minor changes made in the process from making the book into a. Rita hayworth and the shawshank redemption is a short story by stephen king from his 1982 collection different seasons, subtitled hope springs eternal. In particular, we have been getting requests for the shawshank redemption since we launched the show and finally had the time to get it. This moving and inspirational film follows the book very closely in relation to. In particular, we have been getting requests for the shawshank redemption since we launched the show and finally had. Surprisingly, there were more similarities between the novella and the film then i expected. Andy entered shawshank in 1948 and escaped in the year 1975 27 years. Everything about that considering both as single movie is appreciable.
King writes the story of an inmate of shawshank state prison, andy dufresne, through the point of view of his fellow inmate red. Differences between the shawshank redeption book vs movie page 1. The movie stars morgan freeman and tim robbins as two convicts. The shawshank redemption was actually a stephen king book before it was a movie, and here are the big differences from page to screen. Stephen kings novella rita hayworth and the shawshank redemption is a great book, but the movie manages to be even better in a variety of ways. Filmnovel comparison rita hayworth and the shawshank. Comparisoncontrast essay miranda gregory 14 martin luther once stated if we are to go fonnyard, we must go back and rediscover those precious values that all realin hinges on moral foundations and that all realiry has spiritual control, joseph boyden composes a story of two canadian first nations nho enlist for war and their aunts life entitled three day road. The movie is based on a story, rita hayworth and the shawshank redemption, by stephen king, which is quite unlike most of kings work. Book vs movie the shawshank redemption from book vs. He demonstrates this through the main character andy durfresne. There are a ton of differences between the book and the classic 1994 film adaptation, directed by frank darabont, but those differences lie in. Book vs movie the shawshank redemption replay the margos celebrate the 25th anniversary of this. Free essays on the shawshank redemption compare contrast red. His surname is redding, but in the book its shortened to red because he has red hair.
Differences between the shawshank redeption book vs movie page 2. Differences in the movie and book of shawshank redemption essaysthe novella the shawshank redemption and rita hayworth, by stephen king, is the basis of the 1994 movie the shawshank redemption directed by frank darabont. The shawshank redemption is a 1994 american drama film written and directed by frank darabont, based on the 1982 stephen king novella rita hayworth and shawshank redemption. It is based on shawshank redemption and the stephen king novella rita hayworth. I feel all the changes made in the movie are for the better since they help really put the redemption in shawshank redemption and also gives a more. The movie was released in 1994 with the understandably shortened title the shawshank redemption. Comparing the book and movie of the shawshank redemption is like comparing a warm chocolate chip cookie and a brownie right out of the. The shawshank redemption was a dud upon its theatrical release in 1994, yet somehow it made a lasting impression and became the classic that it is today. Comparison of just mercy and the shawshank redemption 1644 words 7 pages. Free essays on the shawshank redemption compare contrast. In spite of the fact that the film is based on the novella by s.
83 733 1205 439 276 114 691 141 45 1516 1341 395 1512 21 1218 833 270 310 673 1192 698 1389 1214 1399 130 799 368 1015 531 11 1366 506 1289 819 411 80 309 848 807 1344 373 1364 413